A website broker earns its commission when there is a profitable business to sell, plenty of buyers to reach and a complicated deal to manage. A direct buyer makes more sense when the site has no profit, the pool of interested buyers is small and you want a quick, simple agreement. For a running business, use a broker. For a dormant website, a direct buyer is often the more realistic route.
Brokers win on profit, direct buyers win on dormant sites
Brokers are paid from the sale, and the buyers they bring price sites on profit. That model works well for an established online business and poorly for a site whose business has closed. A direct buyer has already decided what kind of site they want, so there is no listing period and no commission, but you carry more of the work of checking the buyer.
The Blue Ocean Websites is a direct buyer for one specific kind of asset: the website of a former real business that is still indexed, gets at least 500 monthly organic traffic visits as estimated by Ahrefs, has two or three strong authority links and a brand that still ranks. We prefer lease-to-own, typically roughly $300 to $500 per month per site until the agreed price is paid in full, and can buy outright for the right asset.
How the two routes compare
| Factor | Website broker | Direct buyer |
|---|---|---|
| Fees to you | Commission on sale, sometimes an upfront fee | Usually none |
| Time to a deal | Months; 130 days on average at Empire Flippers | Often weeks, after checks |
| Reach | Many buyers, competitive bids | One buyer at a time |
| Who it suits | Profitable businesses with clean records | Dormant sites, or owners wanting simplicity |
| Typical requirements | Profit and revenue history | Depends on the buyer; ours are traffic, links and brand |
| Who handles the process | The broker | You and the buyer, with escrow for lump sums |
| Certainty of closing | High for qualified listings | Depends on the buyer’s transparency and the written agreement |
| Payment | Lump sum, sometimes with an earn-out | Lump sum or monthly, depending on the buyer |
What brokers and curated marketplaces charge, and how long they take
Strictly speaking, Empire Flippers is a curated marketplace with brokers on staff, and Flippa is an open marketplace with an optional brokered service, while FE International works as a traditional advisory broker. Owners compare all three when they look for help selling, so their published terms are the useful benchmark.
Empire Flippers takes 15% on most sales under $700K, with a $10,000 minimum, and requires at least $24,000 net profit per year and 12 months of consistent revenue. Its public scoreboard shows an average of 130 days to sell and sales at 86% of list price on average.
FE International works on success fees only, with no upfront listing cost, and its sell page claims a 94.1%+ success rate on closed deals and more than 1,500 acquisitions. Flippa offers a brokered option with upfront tiers of $399, $499, $899 and $1,299 on six month terms, alongside a success fee shown as 10%.
On timing more broadly, Flippa says mid six-figure deals take around 90 days to close when the books are clean, and seven-figure deals six months or more.
Why commission maths rarely works for a dormant site
Commission is fair payment for work, but its size depends on the sale price, and a dormant site’s price is usually modest. Take an illustration. Suppose a broker-style sale of a closed store’s website would realistically fetch $15,000. Under a flat $10,000 minimum fee, two thirds of the price would go in commission. Under a 20% commission, $3,000 would. Add an upfront listing fee on some services and several months of waiting, during which you still pay hosting and renewals, and the net figure shrinks further.
This is why many brokers politely decline dormant sites: the work is the same as for a larger deal, but the fee the sale can support is small. It is a sensible business decision on their part, and a useful signal for you. If a broker declines, the site has not been judged worthless; it has been judged a poor fit for a commission model.
When a broker wins
A broker is the better choice when the business is still running and profitable. Brokers prepare the financials, write the listing, qualify buyers, manage due diligence and keep the deal moving. Competitive bids from several buyers often lift the price enough to cover the commission and more.
Brokers also win for complex deals: several assets, staff, supplier contracts, an earn-out or a company sale rather than an asset sale. If you have never sold a business and the amount is significant, a good broker’s experience is worth paying for. And if your site is profitable, it will rarely get a better result from a direct lease than from a broker.
When a direct buyer wins
A direct buyer is the better choice when the site has value a broker cannot easily price. A closed store, a shut-down app or a former local business may have years of traffic and links from press, associations, universities or suppliers, but no profit. Brokers usually decline these, and as we explain in why marketplaces reject most dormant sites, listing them often produces little.
It also wins on cost and speed. There is no commission and no exclusivity period, and a buyer who already knows what they want can usually agree terms in weeks. With us, hosting, renewals and upkeep pass to us from day one.
The trade-off is that you must check the buyer yourself. Insist on a written agreement before any transfer, use escrow for lump-sum payments, and read our list of red flags in website buyers. A fair direct buyer will answer plainly, will not pressure you and will not ask for the domain before terms are signed.
Questions to ask either one
Whether you talk to a broker or a direct buyer, the same handful of questions separates a solid offer from a weak one.
- What exactly will I pay, and when? For a broker, ask for the full fee schedule, including any upfront fee, the commission and who pays escrow. For a direct buyer, ask for the total price, the payment schedule and what happens if payments stop.
- How long until the deal closes? Ask for a realistic timeline, not a best case, and what could delay it.
- What do you need from me? A broker will want financial records. A direct buyer like us will want access to traffic data, such as a Restricted user in Search Console, and proof that you can transfer the domain.
- What happens to the site afterwards? A fair buyer will answer plainly. Our answer: we take over operations and keep the site online; the details depend on the site and are discussed on the call.
- Is everything in writing before transfer? If the answer is anything other than yes, stop there.
Can you do both?
Yes. Many owners ask a broker first. If the broker declines because the site has no profit, a direct buyer is the natural next step. Brokers sometimes do the reverse, bringing a dormant client site to a direct buyer because it does not suit their listings. If a broker represents you, they can contact us for you, and the same basics and written agreement apply.
Owners with several sites can split them: profitable sites to a broker, dormant ones to a direct buyer. Whatever the route, the transfer itself works the same way, with the auth code, any registrar locks and escrow where needed, as our website transfer guide explains. This is general information, not legal advice. Have a lawyer review any agreement that matters to you.
Which to choose
- If the site has at least 12 months of steady profit, start with a broker or a curated marketplace.
- If the deal is complex or large, use a broker even if a direct buyer appears.
- If the business has closed and the site has traffic, links and a ranking brand but no profit, approach a direct buyer.
- Whichever you choose, get everything in writing and never transfer the domain before the terms are agreed.
What to do next
- Decide honestly whether the site still earns money. That answers most of the question.
- If a broker has already declined the site, note their reasons; they are useful evidence for the next conversation.
- Send us your site for a free valuation, directly or through your broker, or first check it against the basics with the free website value check.
Frequently asked questions
How much does a website broker charge?
Published fees vary. Empire Flippers takes 15% on most sales under $700K with a $10,000 minimum. FE International works on success fees only, with no upfront listing cost. Flippa lists brokered tiers with upfront fees of $399 to $1,299 for six month terms alongside a success fee shown as 10%. Always ask for the full fee schedule in writing before you sign.
Will a broker take on a website with no revenue?
Rarely. Brokers are paid from the sale price, and buyers they work with mostly price sites on profit, so a site with no revenue is hard for them to place. Empire Flippers, for example, requires at least $24,000 net profit a year and 12 months of consistent revenue. A dormant site often fits a direct buyer or a lease-to-own deal better.
Is it safe to sell a website directly to a buyer?
It can be, if you follow a few rules. Get a written agreement before any transfer, never hand over the domain before payment terms are fixed, use escrow for lump-sum payments, and ask the buyer plainly what they will do and how payments work. Walk away from pressure tactics or vague answers. Ask a lawyer to review the agreement if the amount matters to you.
Is a direct buyer faster than a broker?
Usually. A broker needs time to prepare a listing, market it and qualify buyers, and Empire Flippers reports an average of 130 days to sell. A direct buyer who already knows what they want can often agree terms in weeks, after checking the site. Speed is only useful with certainty, though, so check the buyer as carefully as they check your site.
Do you work with brokers or only directly with owners?
We work directly with whoever has the right to transfer the site, which includes owners, heirs, agencies, liquidators and brokers acting for a client. If a broker represents you, they can send the site through our form on your behalf. We look for the same basics either way, and every deal is set out in a written agreement before any transfer.
Find out what your website is worth before it expires.
Send us the site in about a minute. We check index status, organic traffic, authority links and history, then come back with a cash offer, a monthly lease-to-own option, or a plain no.
Get my free website valuation →